We appreciate our customer’s feedback!

As a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant, Agatina’s welcomes all to come and try our authentic Italian-American cuisine. It is our goal to ensure everyone is fed right and satisfied with their meal here. We value our customer’s feedback. If you have been to Agatina’s, click on the link below to share your feedback!

What our Customer’s Say!

Red sauce in Rochester, NY | Agatina’s

Great service and food.The chicken Parmigiano was the best I’ve ever had.. marinara sauce was excellent. The scallops and fettuccine pesto also got rave reviews.

Ken L.

Friendly service and great food with generous portions. I’ve learned from past experience that you have to make reservations for this place, and I can see why. Highly recommend!

Thomas D.

It was our first time eating there, and the food was delicious and were good size portions, the serve was fabulous, and the price was reasonable. I would eat there again!

Patrick D.

For questions about reservations or to purchase a gift card, please contact us.

 2967 Buffalo Rd,

Rochester, NY 14624


Phone: 585-426-0510

Fax: 585-426-0208

Email: mfornataro@agatinas.com


Regular Dining Hours
Monday - Thursday: 4:00PM - 8:00PM
Friday - Saturday: 4:00PM - 8:30PM

Private Luncheons Available
Monday – Saturday
Closed Sundays