Take Your Tastebuds On A Trip At Agatina’s!

Treat your tastebuds to homestyle Italian-American comfort food at Agatina’s. We offer a casual and relaxing atmosphere with freshly made food and great company. As an Italian restaurant located in Rochester, NY, we deliver only the freshest ingredients and most delicious meals.

Everything we serve is made to order for you. From our catering options to our extensive gluten-free menu, we have a meal to satisfy anyone’s taste palette. You can indulge in savory seafood or tasty eggplant parmesan and finish your meal off with handmade cannolis at an affordable price.

Homemade sauce in Rochester, NY | Agatina’s

Our Story

For over 35 years, Agatina’s has served Rochester, NY, and surrounding areas with homemade, fresh Italian cuisine. Our extensive menus have been crafted to suit any individual that visits our restaurant. Each meal is authentically prepared and delivered to you by professional and kind servers.

We provide a relaxing ambiance with full-service, off-site catering, and private and semi-private rooms available for any special occasion. As a family-owned and operated business, we aim to feed our people right and ensure you leave satisfied.

Homemade Sauce Available

We are proud to offer our very own jarred Agatina’s sauce, which you can purchase at our restaurant or the following stores: Trianos, Gates Big M, Dells Deli, Calabresella, Olindos, ANG Market, Food Town, Pettinari’s Deli, Rubinos, Tops (Hilton, Buffalo Road, and Spencerport), Wegmans (Lyell, Chili, Ridgemont, Mount Read, Calkins Rd. Henrietta)

You can also have our sauce shipped from Calabresella’s!


Agatina’s Italian resturant is the best. Anyone that wants great Italian food this is the place to go.
Great food great service all around this is our favorite place to dine out.”

— Brent O.


Agatina’s was outstanding. The food and service was excellent, and when my wife’s order came out with the wrong selection, they came out and gave us a complimentary right dinner to take home at no charge. I haven’t seen that too often in some restaurants. It certainly made our 47 the anniversary very enjoyable. We shall be returning in the future Thank you, Agatina’s!”

– John G.



My wife and I went there for dinner on a Saturday. When we arrived it was fairly quiet, by the time we left it as very busy. The service was the best I have ever received at a restaurant. Dirty plates were quickly taken, water refilled promptly, food came in a timely manner, just all around great service! Food was very good, the pasta was cooked perfectly for my liking. Sauce seemed authentic, meatballs were tasty. Fried calamari appetizer definitely not what I was used to, but I enjoyed their take on it (Fried, but immersed in aioli sauce). Portion size was excellent, I am a big guy and I couldn’t finish my dinner. Overall a very good experience and I’m usually super picky.”

— Ethan

Contact us at 585-426-0510 for a dine-in reservation or catering services.

 2967 Buffalo Rd,

Rochester, NY 14624


Phone: 585-426-0510

Fax: 585-426-0208

Email: mfornataro@agatinas.com


Regular Dining Hours
Monday - Thursday: 4:00PM - 8:00PM
Friday - Saturday: 4:00PM - 8:30PM

Private Luncheons Available
Monday – Saturday
Closed Sundays